The recovery of unexploded missiles in Punjab after the May 2025 air engagements has quietly drawn attention far beyond India’s borders. What initially appeared to be routine debris collection has now turned into a development with serious implications for modern air combat, defence manufacturing, and regional security.
During the aerial clashes linked to Operation Sindoor, Indian security agencies recovered several Chinese-origin PL-15E air-to-air missiles that had landed on the ground without exploding. Remarkably, many of these missiles were found in an almost intact condition, despite having been launched during active combat.
Initial technical assessments indicate that these missiles were fired by the Pakistan Air Force but failed to function as intended. Instead of detonating near their targets or activating self-destruct mechanisms, the weapons reportedly ran out of propulsion and descended to the ground.
This unusual outcome has triggered concern within China’s defence production ecosystem.
Behind-the-Scenes Review in China
Intelligence inputs suggest that the incident prompted an internal technical review at the China Airborne Missile Academy in Luoyang, the organization responsible for developing the PL-15 missile family. Soon after the conflict, Chinese technical teams were reportedly sent to Pakistan to inspect the remaining missile inventory supplied under earlier defence agreements.
The focus of this review is believed to be the export variant, PL-15E. Analysts are examining why multiple missiles failed during their final engagement phase, particularly the systems responsible for proximity detonation and automatic self-destruction.
One of the recovered missiles carried markings indicating it may have been manufactured around 2015. This detail has raised questions about whether older production batches or aging electronic components were deployed, potentially affecting reliability during real combat conditions.
What Likely Went Wrong
The PL-15E is designed as a long-range air-to-air missile, intended to engage targets well beyond visual range. While China’s domestic version is believed to have significantly higher reach, the export model is understood to operate at a reduced range.
Examination of recovered components suggests that the missile’s propulsion system did not suffer a mechanical failure. Instead, attention has shifted toward its guidance and electronic systems.
Recovered fragments include parts of an advanced radar seeker that allows the missile to track airborne targets independently during the final phase of flight. Early assessments indicate that this seeker may have lost target lock mid-air.
Rather than striking a target or detonating automatically, the missile appears to have continued flying until its fuel was depleted, after which it descended without exploding.
The Role of Electronic Warfare
Indian defence officials have dismissed claims that these missile launches resulted in the loss of Indian fighter aircraft. Instead, the outcome has been attributed to effective electronic warfare measures.
Indian Air Force aircraft involved in the engagements are equipped with advanced systems designed to detect, confuse, and jam incoming threats. These systems can disrupt communication links and radar signals that missiles rely on for guidance.
By interfering with the missile’s ability to “see” or track its target, Indian aircraft may have caused the weapons to lose direction entirely. Once guidance was lost, built-in safety mechanisms should have triggered destruction, but those systems appear to have failed in multiple cases.
A Rare Intelligence Opportunity
For India’s defence research establishment, the recovery of largely intact missiles offers a rare technical advantage. Access to real-world adversary weapon systems allows engineers to study materials, electronics, and design choices that are otherwise hidden behind secrecy.
Such analysis helps improve defensive systems, refine electronic countermeasures, and update threat databases used by combat aircraft. These insights are expected to influence future Indian fighter platforms and upgrades, making them better prepared against similar weapons.
Importantly, this knowledge is gained without the risks or costs of direct testing, as the systems were recovered after real combat use.
Why This Matters Beyond the Military
Although the subject involves advanced weapons, its impact extends well beyond defence circles. Effective electronic warfare reduces the likelihood of aircraft losses and limits escalation during conflicts. This directly lowers the risk of wider war and civilian harm.
Strong defensive capabilities also act as deterrence. When adversary weapons fail to perform as expected, it reshapes strategic calculations and discourages prolonged confrontation.
Additionally, reduced dependence on foreign defence imports strengthens long-term economic and security planning. Investments in domestic research and counter-technology help protect national interests without constant escalation.
The Bigger Strategic Picture
The incident highlights a core reality of modern warfare: technological resilience matters as much as weapon range or speed. Advanced systems are only effective if they perform reliably under hostile conditions.
For China, reviewing export weapon performance is critical to maintaining credibility in the global arms market. For India, the incident reinforces the importance of electronic warfare and indigenous defence capability.
What landed quietly in the fields of Punjab may not have exploded, but its strategic impact could influence air power calculations across the region for years to come.
